I can see that it may be more of a cause
for concern or a noise nuisance. The editor asked me if I would explain what
is up there, why they don’t bump into each other, and what are the basic
rules. I will do my best, but please keep in mind that because it is all
governed by various laws, such as the Air Navigation Order (ANO), this is a
simplification – as with most things legal there are all kinds of special
cases and exceptions! Please take what is written as the spirit, not the
letter of the laws.
First of all aviation is split into three groups –
Military (who have their own rules), Commercial (Airliners) and General
Aviation (the rest including everything from small business jets to hot air
balloons including light aircraft, historic ex military aircraft,
microlights and gliders). In Chipping Norton we get all three, though the
commercial stuff is very high in the sky so you needn’t worry about it,
unless something falls off or they empty the sewage compartment by mistake!
All
of these aircraft fly in two kinds of airspace, controlled (of which there
are various kinds) and uncontrolled. Aircraft operating in controlled
airspace, which includes the air corridors and routes that commercial
traffic travels in, the airspace immediately around an airport, certain
manoeuvring areas and the like, rely on some form of air traffic control to
keep them apart. The aircraft are told what to do, and although they are
responsible for keeping a look out and not bumping into someone who isn’t
where they should be, and this keeps everything very safe. In the case of
commercial airliners they are controlled one way or another from the start
of their journey to the finish and fly by special rules, more of which
later. Indeed the only time when they are not directly being controlled in
terms of height, course and speed by Air Traffic Control (ATC) is the couple
of minutes during and after take-off and before landing. Air traffic
controllers will point out to you that most accidents happen on landing or
take off – the only part of the flight where the pilot is fully in charge,
but they might be biased! There are very, very few mid air collisions
involving commercial aircraft, so the odds on one falling on Chippy are
very,very slim.
The second kind of airspace is, unsurprisingly,
called uncontrolled airspace. As its name implies it is not controlled by
any kind of air traffic service, though there may be services, such as the
Lower Airspace Radar Service, locally provided by Brize Norton, to help
pilots with traffic information and avoidance information. The airspace
immediately around Chipping Norton is uncontrolled airspace. Here the basic
rule to avoid collisions is, "see and be seen". It is up to the pilot to
keep a good look out – and if you see anything coming at you head on, turn
right – very quickly! The basic rule is keep right (bit like driving in
France, but less stressful and much safer). When following a ground feature,
such as a road or a railway, to avoid someone coming the other way you keep
the feature on your left. There are also rules about powered aircraft giving
way to gliders. Gliders giving way to balloons, and balloons doing what they
like. Bit like the steam giving way to sail. These rules are based on the
ability to get out of the way – a hot air balloon doesn’t have much
independence in which way it is going and it has no ability to accelerate or
slow down. However, a wise pilot will not put his or her hot air balloon in
the path of a C17 Globemaster transport aircraft on its way into RAF Brize
Norton and rely on the law to get them out of trouble later. The board of
enquiry would unlikely to be attended by the survivors from the balloon!
To complicate matters further there are two sets of
rules by which aircraft fly – one is called VFR, the other is called IFR,
they stand for Visual and Instrument Flight Rules. The former is what the
majority of light aircraft and microlights follow – it is based on being
able to see where you are going and keeping a good look out. The latter
doesn’t make any such rash assumptions as to visibility and is how airliners
are flown – it requires an external controlling agency, in the form of an
air traffic controller when inside controlled airspace. IFR is needed
because people don’t want to wait for their holidays until the weather is
suitable for VFR all the way there and back!
A question that I have often been asked is how low can you legally fly?
In
general this is defined by Rule 5 of the Rules of the Air Regulations 1996.
In rough terms this says that apart from landing and taking off you must be
at least 500 feet from any person, vessel, vehicle or structure (though the
CAA are currently reviewing this). There is also a requirement to be able to
glide clear from a built up area, such as Chipping Norton. In addition there
are further rules covering built up areas, conurbations and outdoor events
with gatherings of over 1000. In the case of built up areas aircraft have to
be at least 1,500 feet above the highest point in the area and able to
alight clear if an engine fails. In addition single engined aircraft are
designed so that they can glide to, and land in an average farm field
without serious risk to the occupants or public in the case of such a
failure. For large out door events aircraft have to be at least 3000 feet
away, either vertically or horizontally. These rules also help reduce the
noise nuisance from light aircraft, something reinforced by noise-abatement
policies adopted by airfields such as Enstone designed to make them good
neighbours. As I said before, the laws make simple explanations difficult.
Another problem with this is that the average person is wholly incapable of
estimating how high an aircraft is above them. In terms of being illegally
too low, if you can’t read the registration letters under the wing then it
probably isn’t – but don’t quote me as an authority for that. In practice in
this country most light aircraft travel round between 2000 feet and 5000
feet above mean sea level. Chipping Norton is about 800 feet above mean sea
level so they should represent no direct danger to those on the ground. The
military are exempt from the low flying rule, though there are restrictions
on what they can do and where, but they do their best to avoid being a
nuisance and try to avoid over flying sensitive areas.
The police also have special dispensations – which
explains why you see the Thames Valley Police helicopter hovering over the
police station on a regular basis below 500 feet. The fast jets spend much
of their time between 200 and 500 feet – which is why you can view them from
above from some building in Chipping Norton as they pass by. These different
operating heights help explain why they don’t bump into each other despite
operating in uncontrolled airspace.
All
pilots, professional or amateur, receive extensive training in all these
rules of the air, the types of airspace, air traffic control services
available to them. What is more they have to
pass exams in them before they may fly on their own. In addition they are
taught where to get weather, airfield information and how to access special
"Notices to Airmen" called NOTAMs that give important safety information
(for example where the Red Arrows will be flying).
Chipping Norton may be in a very busy block of airspace, but the chances of
anyone bumping into each other are fortunately very small. There is no need
to invest in tin hats.
Post
Script. Since this article was originally written in 2003 I’ve been lucky
enough to receive an email from Derek Holloway. Derek lived in Chippy
during WWII, he now lives in Toronto, Canada. The article posed the
question, “Does anyone remember the Harvards?” Here is Derek’s response,
and some closely related memories. I’d like to thank Derek for this vivid
firsthand account; the best kind of history. David Nickson 2009.
“I
certainly do remember Harvards, those "raucous" engines had a sound like
no other flying over the UK at the time. I guess the flying bombs were
the nearest sound in comparison. In the early 1940's, I lived at the
bottom of The Leys, and the Harvard pilots loved to buzz Bliss Mill in
simulated dive-bomber attacks. The night flying was the worst. The sound
was ear-splitting, but in those days there was no Forum to give vent to
your frustration with the noise. Not that it would have done any good
"there's a war on, you know."
Derek
went on to recall another Chippy air crash. “The plane was an
Air-Speed Oxford. It crashed and burned near a farm overlooking the
Common. I can recall clearly my friends and I racing to the crash site
guided by the plume of black smoke. As we ran over the little bridge that
crosses the stream, the firemen were just arriving on the roadway. I
guess we were at the site about ten minutes before they arrived. It
wasn't a pleasant sight, as the Oxford was totally engulfed in flames.
Sitting on the grass with his whining dog at his feet was a very
distressed farm labourer who was crying, ‘I tried to pull him out but his
arm came off.’ As a ten-year-old boy, It was my first experience of the
horrors of war. Others would follow later.”
Derek
also recalled Chipping Norton’s smaller, but still frightening version of
the Blitz. “When Chippy's aerodrome was bombed, I was up early the
following morning and hurried to the site. There was a line of craters in
the grazing field - three if I remember correctly - still smelling of the
explosives. My sister found the largest piece of bomb splinter. It was
nearly a foot long and was marked 1933, so you see Hitler was planning his
war as soon as he gained power. “
© David Nickson 2003
More about
the Author and Local Flying PAGE 2